It’s Time

It’s time


Time for me to make clear
Something I thought
Was obvious when I wrote
The Price of Hate

Most understood
Some asked questions
To clarify rather
Than make assumptions

On that day
And on the days since
I have felt
Unconditional support
And love
Overwhelming love
Healing love
Soaking in to places broken
For far too long

But today
In the midst of
Bathroom bills
In the aftermath of
Orlando
In the facebook posts
Run rampant
It is apparent
Some of you missed
What I said
Or ignored
What I said
Or forgot
What I said
Or didn’t care
What I said

So let me be
Perfectly
Crystally
Entirely
Explicitly
Proudly
Clear

I am not straight.

I. Am. Queer.

Perfectly
Crystally
Entirely
Explicitly
Proudly
Queer

It is not your business
To know why I claim
That particular word
I am a private person
My sex life
My love life
My romantic desires
Are none of your concern

It is enough for you to know

I am queer

And have always been
Even when I didn’t
Acknowledge or
Understand or
Speak that truth

So when I say
What I need to say
In this moment
Today
I hope your ears
Are open to hear

You are someone who
Matters to me
Whose friendship
I value
A relationship
I hope
Can continue

But …

When you speak hate
When share hate
When you keep silent
In the face of hate
Toward anyone
Who is

Lesbian
Gay
Bisexual
Transgender
Asexual
Aromatic
Pansexual
Intersex
Gender Fluid
Gender Neutral
Two Spirit
Non-Binary
Queer
And any other letter
In the gloriously
Rainbow coloured alphabet
That makes up
The people I claim as siblings

When you tolerate hate
Against my family
You are speaking hate
Against me

It is not
Against an unknown evil
With an agenda
Contrary to God’s will
You are spewing hate
At someone you
Have known for years
Someone you once called
Family
Classmate
Student
Colleague
Youth Leader
Mentor
Pastor
Friend
Or whatever other label
You choose to apply to
What we shared
What connected us

And yes
Sharing posts
Making comments
Supporting political movements
In the name of religious belief that
Vilify
Misgender
Stigmatize
Deny rights to
Denigrate
Dehumanize
Is speaking hate

You are entitled to
Your theology
Your belief
Your point of view
Your fear
Your emotional reaction
To something you
Don’t understand or
Don’t experience or
Don’t acknowledge

You are not entitled
To use any of
Those reasons
To lessen
The innate value
Of another human being
To take away rights
To block protections to
Ensure safety
To make someone else’s life
Harder to live

Be grateful
For the privilege
You have never needed
To realize you have

Use that privilege
Make the world
Safer for all people
Do what the God
You claim commanded
Act justly
Love mercy
Walk humbly with your God
Defend the oppressed
Love your neighbor as yourself

If you can’t
If you won’t
Don’t be surprised
When I decide to
Prioritize the well-being of
My rainbow family
Over your need to
Prove you are
Righteous and faithful
At the cost of
Our mental health
Our dignity
Our lives

I first wrote, recorded and hit publish on this poem in June 2016.

It’s been bouncing around in my head these last few weeks as a rising tide of hate keeps sweeping across the U.S. and is also quite visible in Canada too. I almost decided to update the poem, but then someone might think this is a new phenomenon. It’s not and it wasn’t when I wrote it, but I was new to it. As someone who’d only been out for two years.

I’d never recorded me speaking one of my poems before, but it is too easy for people, especially within the Christian community, to share and make what they think are “innocent comments” without realizing the impact it has on real people that they actually know, so I wanted to make sure there was a human face to these words.

For those who are prepared to engage in respectful dialogue, I welcome your thoughts and am prepared to engage in that conversation with you. I lived and pastored in the evangelical church world, I know that moving away from what we were taught is hard and scary and feels like it must be wrong. The thing I can say now (that I couldn’t have said back in 2016) is God is still here, outside the box we were taught God belonged in. There is good fruit and there is community with other people of Christian faith that gives spaces for questions and being all of who you are.

However, please be aware that your “theological questions” are my day-to-day life.  As such, I may choose to disengage from the discussion and/or block your involvement, if the conversation turns from respectful engagement and generous spaciousness.

Also, in case it wasn’t clear, from the poem, the existence, humanity and dignity of 2SLGBTQIA+ people is not up for debate nor is the existence of faithful 2SLGBTQIA+ Christians.

Excavating Faith

I need to try, I need to make an attempt
to put into words, to even come close to describing
how it feels, what it means, to be able to begin
to reclaim part of my journey set aside
left behind, because it felt no longer mine

it belonged to someone I no longer was
the good little baptist girl
both the one who only pretended belief hoping to belong
and the one who truly believed, who chose her path 
who followed a calling, who made that her life
how could it belong to me, the queer me, the one know I am now

so I did what I do best, compartmentalize it away
(forty years of practice, it is my default coping skill)
out of my story like it never was real
like my story of faith began 
the day I walked my queer self back into a church
drastically different from what I'd known
drawn by a longing I didn't understand, didn't want, and couldn't ignore

any other option hurt too much, too complicated
too confusing, too tied up in an understanding of faith 
that calls me heretic, unrepentant sinner, damned to hell
for learning to love who I was created to be, who I always was
for not being able to tick the required boxes of belief
for being unapologetically queer

problem is those parts of my journey have shaped me
they inform who I am, what I believe
they've left scars that make me hesitant to trust, to engage
some from bad theology, some from my conscious choice
to cut myself off from my history and put that part of my life
back into a closet

but then ... music and a way of being church that feels familiar 
brings unexpected tears, a longing for something I miss?
this church so different, not in form, but in practice
this place, this choir, this priest welcomes
all of you always - no hiding required 

then ... unpacking boxes moved more than once
paper and books and music from a lifetime long past 
much let go, it no longer serves, definitely doesn't spark joy
but at the piano not touched in years
too tied up with the life no longer mine
I wander through the song books
fingers touch keys stumbling at first but finding confidence

tears stream, voice breaks, fingers cease their motion
the same lyrics that spoke before speak more loudly now
God knew the truth of who I was when I had no conscious clue
the words that showed me truth then still show me truth now
that I was known and loved before I knew myself

my queer self hidden but there and known and loved
in the me pretending to believe
in the me following a calling to serve
in the me who thought that part of life gone, never to return
it's still mine but I hear the words differently now
it's easier to hear when you're not hiding

I explore more, give myself permission to connect
to try an expression of faith closer to what I knew before
it's terrifying, but there is being known, being seen for who I am
there is welcome and compassion and people who understand
I breathe more deeply than in the six years since I found my way back to faith
more fully than I have in the ten years since I wrote my way out of the closet the first time

Six years ago on a Saturday night Christmas Eve, I accidentally found my way home
Six years later on another Saturday night Christmas Eve, I found my way home again
on four separate paths
one for the part of me that was Pastor Karen to my kiddos now long grown to adulthood
one that feels like the home where I found my own faith the first time
one for the part of me that revels in worship contemporary and free
one that is home where my queer self found faith again

maybe I don't need those from earlier in my journey to accept who I am now
though some have and I am grateful for that grace
maybe I need to give myself permission to be all of who I am 
not only as queer me
but as queer me whose journey of faith looks like more than one single path

It’s taken me since Christmas Eve to put this into something that feels close to capturing the shift that’s been happening.

With much gratitude to those who have been pastors, guides, mentors and friends along the path in all of its parts. There are too many to name, but some, both recent and so very not recent, need special mention for their part in my faith journey over the years and especially in these last few months.

To Devona, to my Spring Garden family back in the day (John, Rick, Margaret and Blake), to Wilkie, to Gene, to Shannon and Brian, to my St. John’s home now (Alastair, Patrick, Gillian, Kevin, Bill, Ruth, Stephanie and John), to Daniel, to Matt and the Monday night crew.

Untitled – December 6, 2022

I remember
with crystal clarity
the moment I knew
not broken just
Queer

years of feeling
not enough
unknown, afraid
no matter how hard I tried
still somehow
not right, not who I should be

I'd found my way out
out of the world inside the closet
I didn't know I was living in

I know now I'm not
inherently broken
but years of broken
sinful humanity
years of so broken
Jesus had to die
to make me worthy of love
so broken ...

it leaves scars

scars I ignore
or try to forget
or pretend don't exist
until ...

someone speaks truth
about the brokenness of
theology that hates and fears

something shifts
just a tiny bit
but enough I can feel
enough I can breathe more fully

---------------------

With gratitude to the person who told me: “The broken ones are those who fear so much they hate. … I hope you continue to heal from being treated like you were broken by people who are broken; and finding peace and joy in being all that you are.”

Most of the time I know what the title is for something I’ve written, but not for this one. Maybe it has no name because I didn’t plan to write, but I also couldn’t ignore the need to put pen to paper and capture what felt like an almost imperceptible shift that mattered in ways I’m not sure I have words yet to express.

The Price of Hate

I wanted to do this
In my own time
To wait until I was ready
Until I had the answers
Rather than questions
I’m still asking myself

I wanted to do this
When I felt secure
To wait until I’d talked
With those I owe
Deep levels of trust
To share face to face
Or at least Skype to Skype

I wanted to do this
After I’d told my family
To wait until the perfect moment
Had revealed itself
And I was ready for
Every potential response

I wanted to do this
When I knew how to explain
Forty years of truth
Buried so deep
All I knew was brokenness

There is an awkwardness in
Maintaining silence
My safety net of procrastination
Wrapped tightly
Trying to contain the
Chaos of rediscovery

But something happened

Ten thousand children
Thrown away
And my silence feels like complicity
My safety net of waiting
Feels wrapped around my throat
Taking away my breath
Cutting off the words I ache to speak

There is no right time
I may never be ready
I may never be able to explain
There is only the moment now
And in this moment
My safety net must unravel
Else I lose the ability to speak

Heart broken

Ten thousand children
That’s how much some people hate
People who also claim belief in a god
Whose very scriptures teach
Love your neighbour as yourself
Care for orphans and widows
In their distress

Ten thousand children
Starving and in need
Support ripped out from
Under their precious lives
An act of hate
Called righteousness
In the name of protecting
Orthodoxy
From the scourge
Of homosexuality

How can people
Called to be like the god they claim
Who has named himself Love
Hate us at such a price to
Ten thousand children

Tears fall as words flow
Years of learning
Straight was right
Queer was sin
My heart breaks
Am I the only one
Who feels the stab of
Soul-crushing guilt
As if my existence
Is somehow to blame for
Ten thousand children
Dropped in a heartbeat of hatred
When one organization
Makes the tiniest movement
Towards acknowledging our rights
As human beings
Created in the image
Of the divine

This is also the price of hate
But unlike ten thousand children
I have a choice
I will not pay their price
I will not take on that guilt
Being queer does not
Equal broken
Nor does it mean excluded
From the faith of my childhood

I will stand up
I will proudly claim my truth
I will meet their fear
With love
For myself
For the world around me
Even for those who hate
Together may we stand in the gap
For ten thousand innocent children

—–

If you haven’t heard about what happened that caused ten thousand children to lose their sponsors through World Vision in the United States because a powerful group of people who call themselves Christians decided fighting against gay rights was more important than caring for the most vulnerable among us, you can read the details here, here or here, just to point you to a few.

I already sponsor a child through Compassion Canada whom I plan to continue sponsoring until she ages out of the program. I am pondering sponsoring another child through World Vision Canada which follows Canadian laws regarding non-discrimination.

—–

I first posted this poem on my blog [yes, the name of that blog used to be here but now it’s not] on April 7, 2014. Sharing the post on facebook was my coming out. I am so grateful for the love and support I have received from family and friends.

Glimpses

Tegan and Sara Concert

I hear a whispered voice
Full of childlike wonder
Excited to be in this place
To be with these people
To know her mother belongs
And by extension so does she
Her mother smiles
And quietly speaks
The queer community
It’s large and diverse
I see the smile on her face
Reflecting the joy
Radiating from her child’s face
Unobserved I find myself
Smiling in return
I understand the wonder
My eyes mirror the same

Standing in line
Quietly I watch
Sweet and so earnest
Yet wary to meet another’s eye
Trepidation visible in every pore
Would someone question
The choice of gendered washroom
What assumptions are being made
Our eyes quickly catch
I smile in welcome
Older femme to young, baby butch
I know the fear of assumptions made
Wish I had known myself that well
When I was still so young

My eyes are drawn in
Beautiful woman leans over
Shares a gentle kiss
With her much loved wife
Their tenderness obvious
Telegraphed across the distance
Of the sold-out theatre
My heart expands
With hope
Possibilities newly dreamed

The crowd is diverse
Encompassing gender, age
Sexuality and race
But visible across the spectrum
Whatever initial each of us claim
Our queerness is celebrated
Proudly proclaimed
In this space any need
To hide or pass
Far from our minds
These are our people
Music born from stories
That we call our own

—–

Primarily written during intermission at the Tegan and Sara concert early in March 2014.

Afraid

My brain says
It’s no one’s business
But my own

Why do I need
To tell everyone
Their assumptions
About me are
Flawed

Why should I need
To announce
I’m queer
Not straight

Why can’t I simply
Live my life
Love who I love
With no need of
Explanation

On the surface
That path should be
Available
Completely reasonable

My sexuality
Is my business
The only other
Who needs to know
Someone I have not met
Yet

My heart says
I can’t move beyond
Dreaming

If I’m afraid to claim
The truth of who I am
If I’m afraid of
Needing to explain

Forty-thee years of denying
Forty-three years of hiding
Not just from them
But even harder
To comprehend
From myself

That’s the question
I don’t want to answer
How could I
Live my life
So completely
Unaware
Repressed
Oblivious
Hidden
Lost
Broken
Afraid

Striving
To be someone
I never have been

Rather than being
The me
The world around
Said was sinner
Flawed
Disgusting
Abomination
Hated by God

So I hid
So deep
In such darkness
It took
Forty-three years
To find my way back
To myself

But I am still afraid

Tonight

two months ago
life felt different
I felt different
walking into the theatre
excited to hear the music of
Amy and Emily, the Indigo Girls
I knew who I was
what I was
but felt like
an interloper
not a fraud, but unsure
could I possibly belong
afraid to make eye contact
afraid someone might see me
ask questions I was
afraid to answer
yet, I felt at home
a sense of kinship
of commonality
wanting to pitch a tent
stay until the dawn came
afraid the moment
would slip away
never to return

tonight Tonight Self-Portrait
walking into the café
excited to hear the stories of
Ivan E. Coyote and S. Bear Bergman
I am confident
in my own skin
I primped, I preened
enjoying the feel of my hair
savouring each moment
dressing to please myself
open to another’s gaze
curious, ready to explore
should the opportunity arise
but on my terms
not desperately seeking
hoping the attention
of some man, any man,
would mark me as acceptable

tonight I know
I am queer
I am femme
I am enough

One Choice

Artwork in photograph by Kelly Rae Roberts

terrified
of not belonging
lesson learned in childhood
stepping outside
the expected path
will leave you
bereft
your longed-for blue
five speed bicycle
returned and no place
for you
at the family table
 
 
you understand the story
of your past
daily seeking a new path
of faith that belongs
to you
despite the inherent
familial tension
springing from
choice made necessary
to survive
with soul intact
 
 
freedom found
in learning to listen to
your body
your heart
your soul
reveals stories
buried deep
hidden from all eyes
even your own
your truth denied
 
 
in the world
you grew in no
other possibility existed
never imagining
your reality could be
so entirely different
from the life
you learned to live
hiding brokenness
never healed
blamed on fear
of always being
on the outside
 
 
now you have
family of choice
circle of belonging
sense of community
rarely experienced before
but they don’t know
your truth
closeted away beyond
even your own gaze
 
 
childhood terror steals
your breath
your words
when you ponder
revealing the truth
you’ve now begun to own as
My Truth
 
 
fear of exclusion
rejection
losing your place
in the circle of trust
you’ve struggled to find
will they feel betrayed
is there possibility
of understanding
acceptance
embrace
in the midst of
your bewilderment
 
 
forty-three years
of hiding your truest self
so far away
you didn’t understand
all your efforts would
never fix you
the core wasn’t broken
you were just queer
trying desperately to live
an expected straight life
not your own
 
 
the dilemma you face
explore your truth
loudly and proudly
risking the place
you’ve finally found
hoping you still
belong
 
or
 
keep the life
you’ve built
stay quiet, hidden
pretending contentment
losing yourself
bit by bit
slowly dying inside
 
 
only one choice
for living exists
simple survival insufficient
fullness of life
once glimpsed
must be embraced
even if cost leads to
fear realized